Feature Article

Developing Devices That Are Just What the Doctor Ordered


Posted in Design Services by Brian Buntz on October 17, 2012

Designing devices that precisely match real-world clinical needs depends on establishing effective partnerships with end users. Too few companies are doing that, or doing it poorly.


Engineers are only human. And when it comes to developing products that end users actually want to use, they don’t always get things right. While engineers play an integral role in product development, the majority of medical devices on the market—from stents to ingestible sensors—were developed in close collaboration with physicians and other experts.

Clinicians have a key role to play in the development of medical technology, says Elizabeth Muir, project coordinator at Trustech (Manchester, UK; www.trustech.org.uk), an NHS organisation that seeks to foster the development of innovative medical products. “We encourage companies to get their input early in the design process,” she says, adding that her organisation regularly encounters inventors who have spent lengthy portions of their lives and sizable sums of money refining inventions with limited or no ultimate clinical need. 

Although physicians are routinely involved in the development of new medical technologies, there are many products on the market that are not widely adopted because they don't conform to their real-world needs and desires. Image from Flickr user opensourceway

Kathryn Stecco, MD, a medtech entrepreneur based in San Jose, CA, USA, who regularly oversees clinical trials in Europe, has similar thoughts. Although physicians are commonly involved in the development of medical devices, engineers generally would benefit from getting out in the field more often and developing closer ties with doctors, she says. “This is a huge problem in the industry. There are so many companies that seek limited physician input in product development,” she adds. “A lot of engineers in the medical device space are reluctant to seek outside help,” Stecco explains.

“In most companies, it is not common practice for engineers to go to a hospital [...] and hang out with clinicians.”
—Fabien Schmitt

The very culture within some medical device companies can be an obstacle to building a long-term collaborative approach with clinicians. For that reason, it is difficult to develop a solid understanding the intricacies involved in clinical decision-making. “In most companies, it is not common practice for engineers to go to a hospital each Tuesday, for example, and hang out with clinicians,” says Fabien Schmitt, Senior Consultant, Technical Design, at London-based design bureau PDD. “Frequently, spending time with clinicians is something they have to fight for,” he adds. “It is understood that clinician input is important in the early phase of a new design project. But sometimes, especially in larger companies, the marketing department might handle many of the clinician interviews. An engineer doesn’t always get to go along, and that is frustrating for people who really want to understand the user need.”

Another consideration complicating matters is that physicians are notoriously busy and, in the United States, the Physician Payment Sunshine Act legislation may provide a further hurdle limiting physician/industry collaboration. “Still, getting physician input is critical. In this era of digital communications, I would advise engineers to at least have [remote or virtual] conversations with physicians to help them get a better feel for how things are out in the field,” says digital health consultant and former electrophysiologist David Lee Scher, MD. Scher also recommends that engineers having discussions with physicians online on non-public social media sites.

Big versus small

The nature of the industry/clinician relationship can vary depending on the firm’s size. “It is probably easier for big companies, because they have those relationships in place,” Schmitt says. “They already work with physicians who sit on their clinical advisory board on a regular basis. Startups will usually have to do a bit of legwork to establish those relationships.”

“In this era of digital communications, I would advise engineers to at least have [remote or virtual] conversations with physicians to help them get a better feel for how things are out in the field.”
—David Lee Scher, MD

Among startups, the collaborative process often depends on the company founder’s attitude. “Some founders understand that working closely with clinicians is critical to success, and they create a company culture to [foster] that,” Schmitt explains. “Others position themselves as the main conduit of clinical input into the company and this is obviously limiting,’” he adds.

“The doctors you talk to will, at some point, become your clinical advisory board, if they aren’t already. For that reason, it is important to try to work with a mix of physicians and get a variety of perspectives,” Schmitt says. “A lot of companies go for the most high-profile names because that helps their new product get a higher degree of public exposure. However, in terms of developing a product for the mass market, you want to make sure you talk to physicians with a wide range of skill and experience,” he says. Especially with usability becoming more important in terms of FDA guidelines, there is now more focus than ever on developing a device that minimises the potential for errors, says Schmitt. “Creating something that is intuitive to use and easy to pick up is important. And [gathering] input from people of various skill levels is an essential component in this process.”

Scher stresses the importance of seeking out physicians with a certain degree of altruism. “I’ve seen advisory boards where the physicians are just thinking about what they would like personally. They sometimes don’t put their corporate hat on and thinking of what is good for the company and the rest of the world.”

Viewing problems as opportunities

For whatever reason, there are many products on the market with features that clinicians either don’t use or don’t especially like. As example of the former, Scher points to implantable cardiac rhythm management devices that are often bundled with many features that “doctors don’t use because they don’t know they exist.” Electronic health record (EHR) systems are an example of the latter. “I can’t tell you how frustrated most doctors are with the EHR software used to order tests,” says John J. Pan, a radiologist at Harvard’s Brigham & Women’s Hospital and advisor to radiology startup Nephosity (San Francisco, CA, USA). Nephosity is profiled on the medtechinsider blog. “In the past, if a patient hurt his or her shoulder, a doctor only had to write ‘MRI of the shoulder’ on a piece of paper. But now, he or she has to log into the program and go through at least 50 mouse clicks and enter a bunch of information in multiple drop-down menus,” he adds. “And of course, every click is a chance for an error to occur.”

“So that is the challenge: to come up with something that is really, truly easy to use and makes doctors’ lives easier.”
—John J. Pan, MD

“When I try out a new product, if I don’t like it after using it a couple of times, I am not going to use it again unless I have to,” Pan says. “Physicians have way too many things to think about,” he says. “So that is the challenge: to come up with something that is really, truly easy to use and makes doctors’ lives easier.”

On that note, Florian Altmann, Health Lead Europe, IDEO GmbH (Munich) advocates bringing a consumer design focus to medical technology. “One could think that designing for well-trained professionals, such as pilots or physicians, [would be] similar and completely different than [designing] for consumers.” In the end, though, the user experience for any product is based on emotional response and user preferences and options. “These emotional drivers can be strong enough to make or break all efforts. This means that we treat design in the area of healthcare as we would treat design for consumers.”

Watch and learn

A good number of medical device ideas for future products come from influential physicians who, when evaluating a device, gives the manufacturer feedback on the technology. Another approach is based on the simple observation of clinical workflow. For instance, IDEO designers Arvind Gupta and Danny Stillion had observed in watching spinal surgery that a surgeon was unable to touch a 3-D navigation device because its surface was not sterile. Surgeons had developed a frustrating workaround where they would ask a nurse to touch certain parts of the touch screens on their behalf. To address the issue, the designers developed a sterile mouse for surgeons to put them in direct control of the device. 

medtronic navigation

In 2006, design firm IDEO assisted Medtronic in the development of the StealthStation surgical navigation system for spine surgery. IDEO spent three months doing clinical observation work in a number of hospitals observing surgeries in a variety of hospitals to learn about the workflow in the operating room. 

When doing field research, it is often helpful to bring along people who can observe clinical workflow with a fresh eye, Schmitt recommends. “Sometimes a surgeon will have spent 10 years working with a certain instrument. He or she will be performing a task in a certain way without realizing, for example, that the instrument is putting additional strain on the body because of bad ergonomics,” he adds. “Sometimes a product doesn’t change simply because there are insufficient incentives for the stakeholders to change the status quo. Specifically,  if companies are making a product that hospitals are buying and the surgeons aren’t complaining, there is a high risk of innovation stasis,” he adds.

“Fresh eyes and experienced collaborators, various backgrounds and open communication ensure that the [well-trod] path is challenged.”
—Florian Altmann

“This is also where an interdisciplinary approach helps to uncover innovation opportunities. Fresh eyes and experienced collaborators, various backgrounds and open communication ensure that the [well-trod] path is challenged,” says Altmann.

Often, the seeds for new products are planted when a medical device sales rep, or another company representative, visits a doctor and hears his or her frustration concerning particular products. “Or they will hear from us what we would really like,” says anaesthesiologist Lynn Webster of the Salt Lake Surgical Center (Salt Lake City, UT, USA), who has assisted companies such as Medtronic, Boston Scientific and Covidien with product development. The dialogue between physicians and industry can vary from a single casual conversation to off-and-on communication that spans a decade or longer, he adds.

While insight from physicians is critical in product development, simply asking a physician what problems he would like to see solved has its own pitfalls. “Physicians generally don’t have an engineering background. So they’ll define the problem in their vernacular,” says engineer and entrepreneur Mir Imran of InCube Labs (San Jose, CA, USA), who holds more than 200 patents and was instrumental in the development of the first implantable cardioverter-defibrillator. “Engineers’ vernacular typically doesn’t intersect very well with [clinical language]. An engineer’s understanding of a clinical problem might be incomplete even after hearing a physicians’ description of it. So unless the engineer is willing to incorporate knowledge of medicine in his or her brain, that person is not going to be a good innovator,” Imran explains.

“Unless the engineer is willing to incorporate knowledge of medicine in his or her brain, that person is not going to be a good innovator.”
—Mir Imran

Extensive clinician feedback is especially important in regards to disruptive innovations that address unmet clinical needs in a completely new fashion. “Disruptive innovations require a deeper understanding of diseases at a very fundamental level. Such innovation requires being able to go backwards and look at the problem in its very earliest form—the disease stage, for instance,” Imran says. This process requires vigorous investigation of both the clinical problem as well as the technology now used to treat it. “The assumptions underlying the problem or the definition of the problem have to be re-examined, and that requires by definition a deeper understanding of both medicine and engineering,” Imran says.

“During all this, the entire ecosystem should be kept in mind, including the ultimate recipient of the care. Ideally, designers and engineers observe the patients-physician-interaction in the disease area in question,” says Altmann in this context.

From brainstorming to idea evaluation

“Once you have a critical mass of information about an unmet need and you have validated it, the next step is to generate ideas on how to address it,” Schmitt says. “When generating ideas, you want to be as broad and creative as possible. Stop yourself and your team from jumping to a solution early on. Try to generate as many ideas as you can knowing they will later be filtered down using selection criteria based on your understanding of the unmet need.”

At this point, it is important to keep the focus solidly on the unmet clinical need rather than a particular technology. “In the very beginning, ideas for new medical devices should be all about helping the patient,” says Zeljko Roncevic, MD, PhD, a pediatric cardiologist based in Mostar in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

“In the very beginning, ideas for new medical devices should be all about helping the patient.” —Zeljko Roncevic, MD, PhD

Engineers are sometimes tempted to pull out a tool to address a clinical problem before completely understanding the need, says Mir Imran. “For instance, a mechanical engineer who has worked with catheters might be tempted to solve every medical problem with a catheter,” he explains. ”Or the engineer may jump to a solution for a clinical need based on a partial understanding of the problem.”

Using the information gained during the needs validation phase, the next step is to filter down the ideas to those that look the most promising. “This part is always very exciting,” says Schmitt, “because you are entering the iterative phase of the design process. As you start fleshing out ideas, building prototypes and testing them out, you will inevitably gain new insights that will lead to a better design.” In this context, usability ought to be seen as an opportunity. “Regulatory changes over recent years have really brought usability into the limelight,” continues Schmitt. “Here at PDD, we are keen to convey to our clients that formative usability studies in particular are a real opportunity to get an edge in the marketplace. By having engineers work alongside human factors experts and designers, the studies can do much more than ‘checking the regulatory box’; they can lead to a richer understanding of the user and thus safer and more user-friendly devices.”

“Sometimes, engineers don’t know what they don’t know. They may think they have a good idea but not know that it has regulatory or clinical problems.”
—Kathryn Stecco, MD

In conversations with clinicians, it is also important to get an understanding of how your product ideas would affect their workflow, and the degree to which your product will require the clinical community to be educated. A product idea may have significant potential to improve patient outcomes, but if it requires physicians or nurses to significantly alter their approach to patient care and, this is a hurdle that needs to be understood and managed. Or perhaps the reimbursement code given to a new product would result in clinicians being paid less for a procedure than if they used conventional technology. “In that case, they might prefer to use the old treatment because there is a hidden financial incentive to do so,” Schmitt says.

For all these reasons, the evaluation process for new product ideas should also involve collaborating with a cross section of experts—not just clinicians. Your team also should include experts on topics such as intellectual property, regulatory pathways, and reimbursement. “Sometimes, engineers don’t know what they don’t know,” Stecco says. “They may think they have a good idea but not know that it has regulatory or clinical problems.”

Brian Buntz is Editor at Large of EMDT sister publication MD+DI.



Find more content on:
Your rating: None Average: 4.5 (2 votes)


Login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I havent any word to

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.
web developer

An interesting dialogue is

An interesting dialogue is price comment. I feel that it is best to write more on this matter, it may not be a taboo topic however usually individuals are not enough to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers.
Auto Alarm Miami

You make so many great points

You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers.
https://twitter.com/newspaper_cat/status/585492182934679552

I found your this post while

I found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research ... It's a good post .. keep posting and updating information.
Rinjani Trekking

I have recently started a

I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work.
watermelonsprinkles.com

http://www.columbiaintegrativ

http://www.columbiaintegrativemedicine.org/erectile-dysfunction-in-young-men-causes-and-treatments/ Erectile Dysfunction In Young Men: Causes And Treatments. Contrary to popular opinion, erectile dysfunction (ED) is not just a problem for middle-aged men and seniors. In recent years, incidents of the disorder have been increasingly reported by men under 40, with a full quarter of all recorded cases now stemming from that demographic. Please visit http://www.columbiaintegrativemedicine.org/erectile-dysfunction-in-young... ...

Thank you for such a well

Thank you for such a well written article. It’s full of insightful information and entertaining descriptions. Your point of view is the best among many.
balkan auto

This is truly a great read

This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!. decorative concrete ma

This is a great inspiring

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
http://arebreastimplantssafe.snack.ws/your-dental-health.html

Thanks for sharing this

Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people..
anunturi pentru romani in uk

What may you recommend about

What may you recommend about your post that you made some days in the past? Any sure? fashionable outfits

I would love to stop by. But,

I would love to stop by. But, I think it might have to wait until this summer. I did not know that Serlkay had ever expanded its size. I must say that a succesful family owned business in this day and age is a very refreshing sight! As well as this is a very refreshing site!
fitness for health

To create a such reasonably

To create a such reasonably article is actually superb,I daily scan your blogs and provides my announcement for that here this text is simply too nice and then amusive. Kunjungi Website

Thanks for taking the time to

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. خرید فیلترشکن جدید دانلود فیلتر شکن

I really thank you for the

I really thank you for the valuable info on this great subject and look forward to more great posts. Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty article with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article. Good luck to the author! All the best!
tool

I definitely really liked

I definitely really liked every part of it and i also have you saved to fav to look at new information in your site.

picture quiz game app

Interesting post. I Have Been

Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks
Sms messages

I have read a few of the

I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog site list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my site as well and let me know what you think.
Rinjani Trekking

hi was just seeing if you

hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
Büroreinigung Hannover

Please continue this great

Please continue this great work and I look forward to more of your awesome blog posts.
seo

I’ve read some good stuff

I’ve read some good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much effort you put to create such a great informative website.
http://besthealthyliving.webs.com/liposuction

Thanks a lot very much for

Thanks a lot very much for the high quality and results-oriented help. I won’t think twice to endorse your blog post to anybody who wants and needs support about this area
Dot Matrix Printer

I can see that you are an

I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.
seo

This is really a nice and

This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it.. dofollow backlink service

This was a really great

This was a really great contest and hopefully I can attend the next one. It was alot of fun and I really enjoyed myself..
Rinjani Trekking Organizer

Wow, awesome blog layout! How

Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The total glance of your website is great, let alone the content! harvokse

I have been checking out a

I have been checking out a few of your stories and i can state pretty good stuff. I will definitely bookmark your blog
Anger Management Groups
Anger Management counselling

Anger Management workshops

Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here.
Anger Management
Anger Management workshops

I havent any word to

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great
Obsession Phrases Free Download
https://www.facebook.com/obsessionphrases

Just admiring your work and

Just admiring your work and wondering how you managed this blog so well. It’s so remarkable that I can't afford to not go through this valuable information whenever I surf the internet!
Canada Goose Coats UK

I definitely enjoying every

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.used car from japan

Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll

Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m happy to find so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.
Canada Goose Norge

I was very pleased to find

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. twitter accounts with profile pictures

I was very pleased to find

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
Salvation Diet PDF
http://www.womenlogs.com/the-salvation-diet-secrets-by-chris-walker/

who have spent lengthy

who have spent lengthy portions of their lives and sizable sums of money refining inventions with limited or no ultimate clinical need. e-factor diet pdf

american shield home warranty

This is also a very good post which I really enjoyed reading. It is not everyday that I have the possibility to see something like this.
american shield home warranty
home buyers warranty
home shield warranty

I can see that you are an

I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.
Viagra

I read a article under the

I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this..
Cremation Jewelry

I felt very happy while

I felt very happy while reading this site. This was really very informative site for me. I really liked it. This was really a cordial post. Thanks a lot!.
rinjani trekking

I will apply to the

I will apply to the development of my blog. Thanks for sharing useful information. buy instagram likes for cheap | how to buy ig followers

This is my first time i visit

This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. cccam server

I found this is an

I found this is an informative and interesting post so i think so it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
Bellevue Towers for sale

I am actually delighted to

I am actually delighted to glance at this blog posts which includes plenty of usefulfacts, thanks for providing such information. rinjani trek

this is my first opportunity

this is my first opportunity to visit this website. I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog. Thanks for sharing useful information.
Giubbotto Canada Goose

I went over this website

I went over this website and I believe you have a lot of wonderful information, saved to my bookmarks
Canadian Pharmacy

Wow what a Great Information

Wow what a Great Information about World Day its very nice informative post. thanks for the post.
https://www.rebelmouse.com

I really thank you for the

I really thank you for the valuable info on this great subject and look forward to more great posts. Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty article with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article. Good luck to the author! All the best!

Melbourne Removalists

Thanks for this great post, i

Thanks for this great post, i find it very interesting and very well thought out and put together. I look forward to reading your work in the future.
The Salvation Diet

What may you recommend about

What may you recommend about your post that you made some days in the past? Any sure?fashion industry

Great post, you have pointed

Great post, you have pointed out some fantastic points , I likewise think this s a very wonderful website.
madagascar nature tours